"The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom" tested: a successful experiment with technical flaws
Review

"The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom" tested: a successful experiment with technical flaws

Domagoj Belancic
25.9.2024
Translation: machine translated

Princess Zelda's first own adventure is a bold and successful experiment. Despite annoying stutters, fans of the series can look forward to an excellent "Zelda" adventure with a pinch of "Pokémon".

"The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom" is going down in the Nintendo history books. For the first time in the history of the game series, I am not controlling the swordsman Link, but the eponymous princess herself.

Instead of a sword, Zelda goes into battle with a magic staff. She can use it to copy objects and monsters and conjure them up as "echoes". This daring gameplay experiment turns many things on their head. Nevertheless, "Echoes of Wisdom" feels like a classic 2D "Zelda".

One fly in the ointment: the occasionally poor technical realisation spoils the gaming experience with annoying stutters. I often wish I could play the game on more powerful hardware.

Win a Nintendo Switch (OLED model) including "The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom" and great merchandise

In collaboration with Nintendo, we are giving away a Nintendo Switch (OLED model) including "The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom" and great merch. All you have to do is answer this question: Which is your absolute favourite dungeon from all "The Legend of Zelda" games?

The competition has ended.

One copy-and-paste, please

Mysterious cracks have appeared in the kingdom of Hyrule, leading to the "void" - a strange parallel dimension in which time stands still. Many disgusting monsters emerge from these cracks. Link, who is usually always on hand to protect the kingdom, has disappeared into one of these cracks. Great. Princess Zelda will have to save the world and close the cracks.

Cracks to nowhere appear everywhere in Hyrule - including in the Gerudo Desert.
Cracks to nowhere appear everywhere in Hyrule - including in the Gerudo Desert.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

On her journey through Hyrule, Zelda is accompanied by "Tri" - a sugar-sweet fairy who gives the princess a magical staff. This really shakes up the tried and tested "Zelda" gameplay.

If I see a sparkling object in the world, I can copy it with the magic wand. Once copied, the item is available to me as an "echo" at any time. Defeated monsters can also be copied and conjured up again to fight for me if necessary.

The monster echoes fight for me while I lean back.
The monster echoes fight for me while I lean back.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

How and where I use echoes is completely up to me. Want an example? I want to get to a treasure chest on a ledge. To get there, I conjure up previously copied beds, stack them and use them as stairs. I could also stack water cubes and swim up them. Or I could clone a spider hanging from the ceiling and use its spinning thread as a climbing rope.

The only limitation I have is the magic available to me. Every cloned item and every monster costs magic points. Once these have been used up, the oldest echo is deleted. Over time, I can expand the magic points available to me with upgrades and thus create more and more blatant echoes.

I don't care how I reach my goal - the main thing is that it works somehow.
I don't care how I reach my goal - the main thing is that it works somehow.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

Inconvenient control

The speed at which I unlock new items and monsters is damn fast. No sooner have I got used to an echo than I find the next item or the next enemy to add to my repertoire. Every few hours, I even discover something that completely turns my style of play on its head - sometimes in the way I approach battles and sometimes in the way I move around the world or solve puzzles.

The more Echos I unlock, the more awkward the controls become. This is mainly due to the cumbersome menu, which is reminiscent of the "Synthesis" ability from "Tears of the Kingdom". The unlocked ECHOs are presented to me in a horizontal line. I can sort them according to various criteria - for example, by the most recently learnt or the most frequently used echoes. The constant scrolling back and forth gets on my nerves after a while. Compared to "Tears of the Kingdom", I would have liked to have seen some progress in the menu navigation.

The selection menu is in need of improvement.
The selection menu is in need of improvement.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

"The Legend of Zelda: Pokémon"

At times, collecting various monster echoes reminds me of "Pokémon". As I roam around the world, I keep seeing exciting new creatures. I really want to "catch" them so that I can send them into battle or use them for other purposes.

Sometimes I deliberately seek out remote places and caves to find exciting monsters. An electrically charged bat? That'll be useful for stunning enemies. A giant plant creature that whirls around and flings enemies away with spikes? That will help me fight large hordes of enemies.

Learning new echoes feels like catching Pokémon.
Learning new echoes feels like catching Pokémon.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

The different monsters even have different levels and their own "types" (fire, water, grass, ice, etc.), which are important in battle. Yes, even a "Pokédex"-like encyclopaedia containing interesting facts about the monsters (and items) has made it into the game. My "Pokémon" heart is jumping for joy.

With fiery monsters, I torch grass and make my enemies sizzle.
With fiery monsters, I torch grass and make my enemies sizzle.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

As if collecting monsters wasn't enough reason to be happy, I meet a mad scientist during the course of the game. He creates new Frankenstein monsters for me. I can use the wind-up robot beasts in battle without magic and in addition to the ECHO monsters. This is particularly useful in larger and more difficult boss battles.

The robots cause chaos on the battlefield. I love it.
The robots cause chaos on the battlefield. I love it.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

A pinch of telekinesis

With the magic wand, Zelda can not only Copy Paste monsters and enemies, but also release telekinetic powers. With the "unison" ability, the princess transfers her movements to other objects or monsters. This means she can even push huge boulders back and forth. Or I can use it to send enemies into chasms and lava to kill them. It's fun and a bit reminiscent of Link's Magnesis ability from "Breath of the Wild".

Moving stones? No problem!
Moving stones? No problem!
Source: Domagoj Belancic

Alternatively, movements of objects or monsters can be transferred to Zelda with the reversed "unison". An example: To climb a steep mountain, I conjure up a spider as an echo and attach myself to it with "Unison". The beast crawls up the mountain and I float along with it. This saves me the hassle of climbing. Very funny.

With the unison ability, I attach myself to the spider and let myself be transported.
With the unison ability, I attach myself to the spider and let myself be transported.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

A little sword is a must

"The Legend of Zelda" purists can breathe a sigh of relief - at least a little. Even the princess can't do without swordplay. After the first dungeon, she finds a magic sword. I can use this to activate a "swordsman mode", with which Zelda controls herself like Link and swings the sword. This means I can actively take part in the battle. Unfortunately, only for a few seconds. After that, I have to recharge the sword with magic resources.

In swordsman mode, Zelda turns blue and can use Link's weapons for a short time.
In swordsman mode, Zelda turns blue and can use Link's weapons for a short time.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

I can gradually upgrade the duration of the mode. But I'm still not really happy with it, even after countless upgrades. I can only find the resources for recharging in the interdimensional rifts. When exploring Hyrule, my magic bar for the swordsman mode is therefore usually empty.

So I often find myself in a situation where I would like to draw my sword myself, but can't do so. This is particularly frustrating when my conjured monster ECHOs are being silly and missing enemies or getting stuck. Damn, now why don't you just kill that Moblin instead of missing or standing around looking stupid!

Big world, awesome dungeons, ingenious puzzles

The world of "Echoes of Wisdom" is large, but not overwhelmingly huge. It took me around 25 hours to complete my adventure. In the process, I completed quite a few side quests and found most of the collectable items.

I explore the world with my horse.
I explore the world with my horse.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

Similar to "Breath of the Wild" and "Tears of the Kingdom", I am free to choose the order in which I explore the regions and tackle dungeons. This freedom feels very refreshing in a 2D "Zelda". Speaking of dungeons: the generic and sometimes disappointing dungeons from the "Breath of the Wild" era are definitely a thing of the past.

Some sections in the dungeons are played from a 2D side perspective. And yes, Zelda can also jump!
Some sections in the dungeons are played from a 2D side perspective. And yes, Zelda can also jump!
Source: Domagoj Belancic

As in previous games in the series, the dungeons are divided thematically. Among other things, I fight and puzzle my way through a scorching hot lava dungeon, a frozen ice dungeon and a water dungeon in the Zoras' territory. The puzzles are reminiscent of classic "Zelda" games. The solution path, on the other hand, is more reminiscent of the new, open game mechanics of the last two Switch spin-offs.

I constantly have to search my repertoire of echoes for the right item (or monster) that could help me solve a puzzle. The "unison" mechanic is also often used when solving puzzles. There is no "right" solution. I often concoct something from my echoes that just barely works, but definitely wouldn't have been the easiest option. I'm reminded of my poor creations and unconventional solutions that I used in "Tears of the Kingdom". Marvellous.

I often have to think outside the box and get creative with the puzzles.
I often have to think outside the box and get creative with the puzzles.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

Off into the "void"

The dungeons in "Echoes of Wisdom" are located in the rifts of the mysterious "Nothing" dimension. Before I can tackle a dungeon, I have to enter one of these rifts and fight my way through a short game section in the parallel dimension. I also find some rifts with access to the "nothingness" independently of the dungeons. In these levels, time stands still and the world is literally upside down. I sometimes find the quirky mini-dungeons even more exciting and successful than the big dungeons.

The nothing world is a success.
The nothing world is a success.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

Aside from the dungeons and the "void", there are numerous smaller caves, treasures and secrets to discover in the overworld of Hyrule. There are also various mini-games and challenges waiting for me. I can take part in a horse race, complete combat exercises with a limited selection of echoes or harvest fruit as quickly as possible. Great!

I'm a little disappointed with the loot that I find in caves or receive as a reward for mini-games. Most of the time, I only get a few rubies or some piddly ingredients for smoothies that I can use to heal myself or regenerate my magic. This is useful, but unspectacular.

I mix drinks with ingredients at smoothie stands.
I mix drinks with ingredients at smoothie stands.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

Beautiful, but jerky

"Echoes of Wisdom" is a sugar-sweet and beautiful game. Provided you can get to grips with the special graphic style, which is reminiscent of the Switch remake of "Link's Awakening" (2019)

The settlements are a highlight for me. The villages are bursting with loving details and the cuddly characters are humorously animated and entertaining with funny written dialogues. The visual splendour is rounded off with an excellent soundtrack, characterised by nostalgic melodies and fresh compositions with a catchy tune character.

I fell in love with the villages and inhabitants of Hyrule.
I fell in love with the villages and inhabitants of Hyrule.
Source: Domagoj Belancic

It's a shame that the technical realisation can't keep up with the harmonious overall picture. Like "Link's Awakening" before it, "Echoes of Wisdom" is often jerky. Particularly in the expansive overworld, I was repeatedly torn away from the action by brief but clearly noticeable frame rate drops - whether in handheld mode or in the dock. At least the uneven frame rate doesn't have a negative effect on the gameplay - I never died due to a stutter or missed a difficult jump onto a platform.

"The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom" is available for Nintendo Switch. The game was provided to me by Nintendo for testing purposes.

In a nutshell

A successful experiment with minor flaws

"The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom" turns the tried and tested "Zelda" formula with the magic wand and the "Echo" clones on its head. The daring gameplay experiment works for the most part. It's fun to find new monsters and items and experiment with them - both in combat and when solving puzzles. Every now and then I wish I could take a more active part in the combat. The limited "swordsman mode" only partially satisfies my desire.

The successful gameplay is spoilt by the cumbersome menu navigation and annoying stutters. I would love to conjure up a "Switch 2" with Zelda's magic wand so that I could play "Echoes of Wisdom" on more powerful hardware without any technical problems. Despite the shortcomings listed, fans of the series can look forward to an excellent spin-off that does a lot of things differently and yet still feels familiar.

Pro

  • Successful "Echo" game mechanic turns many things on their head
  • Collecting monsters is reminiscent of "Pokémon"
  • Classic dungeons with ingenious puzzles

Contra

  • annoying jerks
  • Combat system partly too passive
  • Cumbersome menu navigation
Nintendo The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom (Switch, Multilingual)
CHF45.90

Nintendo The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom

Switch, Multilingual

Nintendo The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom (Switch, Multilingual)
Video games
CHF45.90

Nintendo The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom

Switch, Multilingual

Header image: Nintendo

19 people like this article


User Avatar
User Avatar

My love of video games was unleashed at the tender age of five by the original Gameboy. Over the years, it's grown in leaps and bounds.


Gaming
Follow topics and stay updated on your areas of interest

These articles might also interest you

Comments

Avatar