Paramount Pictures
Review

"Ebenezer": Johnny Depp, you still surprise me

Luca Fontana
12.11.2026
Translation: machine translated

Another adaptation of Dickens' A Christmas Carol? With Johnny Depp of all people? I was skeptical. But 'Ebenezer' is darker, creepier, and above all, more touching than I ever would have expected.

No worries: This film review is spoiler-free. I won't reveal anything more than what is already known and visible in the trailers. «Ebenezer» hits theaters on November 12th.

Johnny Depp is a strange phenomenon. Off-screen, he often appears surprisingly reserved in interviews. Almost shy. Sometimes even a bit lost. Yet, as soon as he stands in front of a camera, he seems to love transforming into the most eccentric characters Hollywood has to offer. Jack Sparrow. Edward Scissorhands. Willy Wonka. Or the Mad Hatter.

The quirkier the character, the better. At least that seems to have been Depp's preferred recipe for decades. That is exactly why I was initially skeptical about «Ebenezer». Because the marketing seemed to rely on one thing above all: Johnny Depp is wearing a crazy costume again, is covered in tons of makeup, and is doing all sorts of strange things. Hooray, he's back!

Especially after years of media frenzy surrounding his legal battle with Amber Heard and the subsequent quiet period regarding his Hollywood career, this almost felt like the film's actual sales strategy. But what about the film itself? Is there so little faith in the story that only Depp's name is needed to lure the audience into the cinema?

Far from it, as it turns out.

What «Ebenezer» is about

London, early 19th century. Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp) is an old, bitter businessman whose heart has long since become as cold as the wintry streets of his hometown. Charity? A waste. Compassion? Superfluous. Christmas, the festival of love? Humbug! Even his good-natured employee Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint) feels Scrooge's contempt for humanity on a daily basis.

>Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit: a kind-hearted man with two truly heartless bosses.
>Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit: a kind-hearted man with two truly heartless bosses.
Source: Paramount Pictures

But on Christmas Eve, the old miser receives an unexpected visit. First, the ghost of his deceased business partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen) appears to him, condemned to eternal torment for his former greed. He warns Scrooge of a similar fate. Three more ghosts will visit him and show him the Christmas of his past, present, and future.

It is Scrooge's last chance to change.

A story no one needs anymore?

Let's be honest: Was anyone waiting for the next adaptation of Charles Dickens' «A Christmas Carol»? Hardly. The story, published in 1843, has been adapted, reinterpreted, and parodied so often that even Dickens would probably be fed up with it at some point. From the Muppets to Disney to Robert Zemeckis' computer-animated version with Jim Carrey: Scrooge's redemption has long been a staple of the Christmas season.

We know the ghosts. We know the lessons. And we know how the story ends. So why again?

>When your deceased business partner comes to visit you at night, it rarely bodes well.
>When your deceased business partner comes to visit you at night, it rarely bodes well.
Source: Paramount Pictures

Perhaps because its message is hardly less relevant today than it was nearly 200 years ago. In a world where greed, resentment, and indifference often seem to take up more space than compassion and charity, it is certainly good to be reminded once again of what humanity actually means.

But that alone would not justify another film adaptation. The decisive factor is how the story is told. And this is exactly where «Ebenezer» differs significantly from its predecessors for me.

The human behind the monster

While other adaptations like to turn the visit of the three Christmas ghosts into a grand supernatural spectacle, director Ti West is more interested in the person experiencing this journey.

Of course, there are elaborate ghostly apparitions here too. But they are never the focus. Instead, West takes a remarkably long time to confront Scrooge with the consequences of his decisions. Not just with what he has done. But with what he has lost as a result. And what he continues to do to other people.

>The ghosts mean well by Scrooge. Even if they don't necessarily look like it.
>The ghosts mean well by Scrooge. Even if they don't necessarily look like it.
Source: Paramount Pictures

Johnny Depp plays this gradual realization remarkably convincingly. Behind the repulsive facade of his Scrooge, something gradually emerges that one would hardly have thought possible at the beginning: a last spark of humanity.

The memories of his one-time great love, in particular, hit me unexpectedly hard. Although I have long known these scenes from other film adaptations and know exactly where they lead, I suddenly found myself sitting in the cinema with moist eyes. West succeeds in giving a long-familiar story a depth I had not expected.

>Ian McKellen is great. But when is Ian McKellen actually not great?
>Ian McKellen is great. But when is Ian McKellen actually not great?
Source: Paramount Pictures

I felt similarly about Bob Cratchit and his seriously ill son Tiny Tim. Rupert Grint has comparatively little screen time, but manages to imbue his Bob with such warmth and quiet exhaustion that you can literally see the weight of his worries. He is a fundamentally decent person who, despite everything, tries to be a good father to his family. This makes it all the more painful for Scrooge to gradually realize how much suffering his own indifference causes.

I was no less impressed by Sam Claflin as Scrooge's nephew Fred. A character who, to be honest, I barely remembered in other adaptations. Here, however, I did. Fred is one of the few people who have not yet given up on their bitter uncle. Year after year, he invites him to Christmas, even though he knows exactly what answer to expect. Simply because he wants to believe that somewhere under all that bitterness, there is still a good person.

>Fred (Sam Claflin) still believes in the good in his uncle. Even if he gives him little reason to.
>Fred (Sam Claflin) still believes in the good in his uncle. Even if he gives him little reason to.
Source: Paramount Pictures

How much heart is in this previously rather inconspicuous character becomes clear especially towards the end of the film. Without giving too much away: one of the most touching scenes belongs to him. And it shows wonderfully why West takes so much time for his characters. Because Scrooge's transformation does not just mean that a bad person suddenly becomes good. It also means that people who have long since stopped hoping for his affection might finally get what they have longed for for so long.

West doesn't just let the well-known resolution rush by either. Where other versions deal with Scrooge's redemption in a few happy final minutes, «Ebenezer» takes its time once again to show what his transformation means for the people around him. That touched me more than I would like to admit.

A Christmas story with horror qualities

The fact that Ti West, who likes to work with A24 and became known for horror films like «X» or «Pearl», is behind «Ebenezer» is clearly noticeable in the film.

His London is beautifully designed, but anything but inviting. Dark alleys, oppressive interiors, magnificent costumes, and an almost tangible atmosphere of cold and decay make the city a place where you wouldn't want to get lost after dark.

Above all, however, the ghosts are actually eerie.

>Horror director Ti West (left) shows Johnny Depp how eerie Christmas can be.
>Horror director Ti West (left) shows Johnny Depp how eerie Christmas can be.
Source: Paramount Pictures

Andrea Riseborough, for example, embodies the Ghost of Christmas Past with such disturbing, almost doll-like body language that I sometimes felt reminded of the animatronic figures in old ghost trains. Her movements seem artificial, her appearance ghostly. Precisely because there is a real person behind it, it has something immensely unsettling about it.

West also sprinkles in genuine horror elements throughout, which give additional weight to the dark themes of Dickens' story: death, guilt, loss, and the fear of a wasted life. Therefore, a warning to parents: don't be fooled by the trailers. «Ebenezer» is not a happy Christmas film for the whole family. Even Zemeckis' already eerie Disney version seems almost harmless in comparison at times.

But – that's exactly what I like. West turns Dickens' Christmas classic into an oppressively serious character study in which Scrooge has to mercilessly confront his past and the consequences of his decisions. This gives his transformation a weight that I have often missed in other adaptations. And it makes «Ebenezer» a completely different film than the sometimes almost slapstick trailers want us to believe.

In a nutshell

More than just another Christmas story

I really didn't think that 'A Christmas Carol' could touch me so deeply again after all the film adaptations. Especially not after a marketing campaign that primarily wanted to sell me Johnny Depp in yet another eccentric role. But Ti West delivers a dark, sometimes frightening character study that unfolds a beautiful emotional note thanks to a convincing Johnny Depp and the empathetic performances of Rupert Grint and Sam Claflin. Added to this are magnificent sets and a wonderfully disturbing ghost design. So does the world really need another film adaptation of 'A Christmas Carol'? Perhaps not. But a reminder of how important humanity is, especially in our day and age, certainly doesn't hurt.
Header image: Paramount Pictures

36 people like this article


User Avatar
User Avatar

I write about technology as if it were cinema, and about films as if they were real life. Between bits and blockbusters, I’m after stories that move people, not just generate clicks. And yes – sometimes I listen to film scores louder than I probably should.


Movies and series
Follow topics and stay updated on your areas of interest

Review

Which films, shows, books, games or board games are genuinely great? Recommendations from our personal experience.

Show all

These articles might also interest you

Show all

These articles might also interest you

8 comments

Avatar
later